BestSuburbs › Adelaide › compare

Allenby Gardens vs West Hindmarsh

Two neighbouring Adelaide suburbs, 0.8 km apart, on the same open data. Allenby Gardens scores higher on 8 of 10 measures.

Allenby GardensWest Hindmarsh
Active4412
Safety5737
Wealth6353
Value7764
Parks8174
Cafés2828
Transit1975
Green space4027
Active & healthy4729
Schools nearby (OSM)9956
Median rent$323/wk $320/wk
Median house price (Apr–Jun 2026)$1,550,000$1,457,500
House sales this quarter32
Population2,0451,560
Full profile Allenby Gardens in full West Hindmarsh in full

Scores are percentiles across all 274 Adelaide suburbs: 100 is the best in the city, 50 is mid-table. Highlighted figures lead the row. How we rank suburbs.

Is Allenby Gardens safer than West Hindmarsh?

Allenby Gardens scores higher for safety (recorded crime per 1,000 residents) between the two, based on official crime statistics.

Which is cheaper, Allenby Gardens or West Hindmarsh?

West Hindmarsh has the lower median house price of the two ($1,457,500 vs $1,550,000).

Should I live in Allenby Gardens or West Hindmarsh?

Allenby Gardens scores higher on 8 of 10 measures across safety, activity, value, parks and cafés — see the full breakdown below, or the complete profile for Allenby Gardens or West Hindmarsh.

Updated October 2026. Compare other Adelaide suburbs →